As I was preparing my dinner, my daughter decided she wanted a juice box. She went to the fridge and pulled out a three-pack. She asked me to break one off but not to peel off the plastic – she wanted to do that part herself. In the interests of preserving the plastic for her, I cut the plastic down the line between two of the boxes. After she had drunk one of the boxes, she reported she wanted another, and that she wanted to “cut” the plastic herself. I was reluctant. My daughter doesn’t have the best track-record when it comes to using sharp tools in a way that I consider safe. Knowing this would likely be much more challenging than cutting paper, I prepared to say “No.” Instead, I said “Yes, if you can find a way to cut it so that the scissors are pointed away from you so that I won’t be nervous.” “Okay she said.” She tried a couple of angles, and with my light guidance, eventually managed to safely cut away the plastic without hurting herself (or me!). As per the book’s suggestions about validating your child’s efforts, especially when they demonstrate something contrary to our role expectations of them (e.g., my daughter is careless with scissors), I quickly followed with “Wow. You really know how to use scissors safely.” “Yeah” she said. At the time she didn’t seem that affected my words, but a few moments later I knew it had actually made quite an impact because of what she chose to do next...
She showed me a picture of me as a child that she had found during the day. She told me she wanted to cut it. Again, remembering from the book to try to give positive options of what your child can do, I said “No, that picture is special to me, but you can cut up this picture” and I proceeded to point at one she had found that didn’t have any people in it. “Okay” she said and grabbed her scissors and the picture and started heading out of the room. “Where are you going?” I inquired. She looked at me and said matter-of-factly “You only like me to cut things up in the library, right?” I was bowled over. A couple of months ago my daughter had become quite obsessed with cutting up every piece of paper she could find and leaving the little bits all over the house. We had had endless arguments about cleaning up after herself and I had eventually resorted to asking her to keep her cutting to the library so I could at least contain the mess to one room of the house. I had never seen any evidence that she had heeded my request much. “Yes, that’s true. Thank you. That is very respectful of you.” Moments later she called me into the library to help her finish cutting the picture. Again, using a technique from “How to talk...” I commented “Oh. I see there are lots of little bits of paper on the floor.” She looked blankly at me. I followed with “Could you pick them up please and put them in the garbage?” (Probably not the best approach according to the book). She hesitated, then said “No but it makes you happy when I cut paper in this room, right?” I responded with “Yes that’s true. But it makes me even more happy when we clean up after ourselves and put the paper in the garbage.” She hesitated, then asked “Okay. Will you help me?” “Sure.” I replied. We picked up the pieces together, at which point I said “Boy, you really know how to clean up after yourself.” “Yeah, I do!” she responded. She proceeded to take the bits of paper to the kitchen garbage. She decided it was too full so asked me to take out the bag, and then... she filled it herself with a new garbage bag! I was quite pleased with us both.
My husband was heading out the door to quickly walk the dog before we all went to bed. My daughter reported she wanted to go on a “family walk.” It was late and I was tired, but knowing that it was unlikely she would fall asleep before my husband got home, and that I hadn’t had any fresh air that day, I replied “Okay. If you get some pants on we can go for a quick walk.” She headed upstairs with my husband to get dressed while I finished my just-prepared pasta dinner. I quickly heard an argument brewing upstairs... “No! I want to wear shorts!” said my daughter in a raised voice. “Mattea, it is too cold for shorts” I heard my husband saying in a patient but slightly exasperated voice. “No!” said Mattea again. She grabbed the shorts and came to find me. “Mommy, I want to wear shorts for our walk.” I thought back to the book again, and how they suggest handling situations where your child acts according to a pattern of behaviour you find unacceptable (I can’t tell you how many of the battles in her life have been related to wearing inappropriately cool clothing). I responded with “Mattea, those shorts are not warm enough for the weather tonight. If you want to go for a family walk, I expect you to find something more appropriate.” (Firm. Stated my expectations. Gave her some wiggle-room to choose something more appropriate.) I wasn’t sure how this one was going to go over. But low and behold, she quickly retorted with “Okay. How about if I wear my shorts and my pants?” “Okay” I replied. She ran off and quickly came back fully dressed.Nothing could have prepared me for what came next though.
When we returned from our walk she started to whimper and whine saying “I don’t want you to ever go to work.” At first I couldn’t hear her through the whimpering and burying her head in my duvet, but eventually I understood what she was upset about. This was a common refrain. I said, “I know, you really don’t like it when I leave.” She started repeating her words with more intensity – “Don’t ever leave!” she said with a grimaced face and her hands locked around my wrist, fingers tense and curled. Wanting to try a new technique, rather than my usual “I know it makes you sad and angry when I go to work” I offered up the drawing solution... “Would you like to draw me how you feel when I go to work?” She immediately stood up straight and said “Yeah!” in an enthusiastic voice. I quickly grabbed a pencil and paper and handed it to her. She looked at me and said “I don’t know how... can you do it?” I took the pencil and made some stabbing motions with the pencil on the paper, thinking this might give her the idea, then passed it back to her. She shook her head “No. I want to write the words, but I don’t know how. Can you write them for me?” “Okay” I replied. I took the pencil and wrote down as she dictated. Here is what she said: “Angry. Sad. Frustrated. Angry. Lonely. Angry. Miss you. Don’t want you to leave.” I had provided some of the suggestions when she couldn’t seem to think of the word. I read her back the list. I was feeling pretty proud of myself when she started her refrain again “I don’t want you to leave. Don’t ever leave!” over and over. It was getting very intense and I was at a loss as to what to do. Her nails were digging into my skin. I felt I was missing something. I tried to think of what other emotion she might have that I/we were missing. Finally, remembering a conversation we had had the previous week in which she had appeared to grasp the concept of death and was quite frightened, I looked her in the eyes and said, “Mattea, are you afraid that if I leave I might never come back?” She immediately burst into tears and wailed “I’m SCAAAAARRRRRRREEEEEEDDD.” She crawled into my lap and sobbed and hugged me “I’m scared you’re going to leave and never come back. And I’m scared that a monster is going to eat me. I need a night-light on when I sleep.” After a good cry, she seemed much better and headed for bed. I suggested we add “Scared” to her list of feelings. She agreed. I wrote it down (she showed me exactly where to write it). Then she asked if we could tape it up on her wall... and she wanted to read the list to Daddy. After doing that, I decided to try one more new strategy. “Do you want to make a list of all of the things you can do when you’re scared?” I asked. She agreed. I started the list with “Call Mommy when you are scared.” She added “Don’t go and never come back” (translation – always come back). I suggested she could ask whomever she was with when I would be home. She said “No, but how are they going to know when you will come back?” I said usually grown-ups know when I will be back. I asked her if it would be helpful if I told her when I would be back. She said yes and we added that to the list. Then she asked me to write “Don’t go and never come back.” I said, “Yes, we have that on the list right here,” I pointed. In a quiet but clear voice that had now lost its urgency, she looked at me with her swollen blue eyes and said, “write it again.”
I look forward to hearing stories from other parents, particularly those in our group last night, about experiences with applying the concepts from "How to talk...".